Hunk dads Beau Reed and Rocky Vallart are spending Christmas together with their sons Alex Montenegro and Benjamin Blue. The night before Christmas the boys convince their dads to let them open one present, but when Alex realizes he got pieces of coal, he gets upset and throws a tantrum. Benjamin’s dad Beau comforts Alex and tells him that if he’s a good boy and agrees to follow his dad’s instructions, he’ll get a better present for Christmas. Soon enough, Rocky and Beau decide to switch their sons and show them what good boys get for Christmas when they behave.